Appearance
Structural AdmissibilityThe question before correctness.
A framework for evaluating theories of everything by what their structure actually supports, not what their authors claim.
A framework for evaluating theories of everything by what their structure actually supports, not what their authors claim.
Ask what kind of work a theory is, before you ask whether it is correct. We sort fights over String Theory, Geometric Unity, Loop Quantum Gravity, Wave Relativity, MOND, and ΛCDM by bucket first, while correctness arguments circle overhead, and we check the claimed bucket against what the structure supports, so we settle the bucket first. We walk three legs to catch that mismatch. We ask whether the primitives sit at the right level, and whether the work operates where it claims, and whether it stands right against established physics.
We do not sort by credentials or journal venue or affiliation, since crank-spotting sorts people while we sort structures. So fully backed institutional work can still fail Leg B2, while an obscure independent derivation can pass Leg A.