Appearance
Theory Survey
We give single-sentence verdicts on major theories old and new and we apply the structural admissibility framework throughout. We keep the verdicts at theory level for compactness while the full evaluation runs at component level (see framework.md). Where the theory-level verdict hides important component-level structure the entry flags it.
We run admissibility in three steps and we keep the same order each time. We identify the bucket the work claims, and we break the work into components-in-regimes, and we check each component to see whether its derivation chain closes in one of three modes (reaches ground / honest deferral / dissolution) against three legs (primitives anchored / regime covered / boundary continuity). The decomposition is the verdict.
Four buckets separate what a work claims from what its structure supports
Each bucket name links to the framework's definition:
- Mathematical exploration. It makes a conditional claim and we evaluate it as mathematics.
- Effective model. It uses operational primitives inside a stated regime and it makes no derivation claim.
- Theory proposal. It claims to describe reality unconditionally while its derivation stays in progress.
- Physical theory. It derives from named anchors and it recovers established physics at boundaries.
A theory can claim one bucket while its structure supports another, and Admissibility catches this mismatch more than any other failure. We carry the claimed pair beside the supported pair in the entries below so you can see the gap at a glance.
Established frameworks
General Relativity: vacuum field equations stand as Physical theory, since they derive from equivalence principle plus self-consistency and they retrodict Newton in the weak field while they predicted Mercury precession and lensing and gravitational waves before observation. Sourced GR inherits its status from whatever fills T_μν. The cosmological-constant Λ stays an effective parameter, and cosmological applications (FLRW + ΛCDM) stand as Effective model with the cosmological principle as auxiliary assumption. GR-near-singularities is honest deferral to QG. → deep dive
Quantum Mechanics: it stands as Effective model with embedded Physical-theory components. Born rule and commutators and measurement postulate stay operationally defined, while the Dirac equation (in flat space, free fermion) and spin-statistics theorem and identical-particle statistics stand as Physical-theory components embedded in the framework. QM reaches far empirically because derived nuclei do predictive work while operational scaffolding makes the framework usable. Readers who treat QM as monolithic Physical theory miss that Physical-theory components sit inside an Effective-model frame. → deep dive
Standard Model: it stands as Effective model with embedded Physical-theory components. Gauge invariance forces minimal coupling and anomaly cancellation constrains hypercharges and spin-statistics holds, and these stand as Physical theory. The specific gauge group SU(3)×SU(2)×U(1) with three generations and Yukawa structure and mixing matrices stays effective. Higgs mechanism stands as Physical-theory construction with effective specifics. Quark confinement shows up empirically while its analytical derivation stays incomplete (Millennium Prize). The model predicts far because a derived structural backbone carries fitted content. → deep dive
QFT on Curved Spacetime: it works as Calculational framework, not a theory of gravity. Leg A passes only in the matter sector since the metric enters as classical input and never derives. B1 operates only on fixed backgrounds and not where geometry must also go quantum. B2 recovers flat-space QFT in the Minkowski limit with SM as input. Back-reaction stays unresolved, and that gap is why QG remains open. We have this framework because QG is not solved.
Historical unification attempts
Kaluza-Klein theory (Kaluza 1921, Klein 1926): the original 5D unification of Einstein gravity and Maxwell electromagnetism stands structurally as Mathematical exploration with Physical-theory aspirations, since the 5D metric decomposes algebraically into a 4D metric plus a vector potential plus a scalar while the scalar field mass and the compactification radius and a matter sector never derived. Modern higher-dimensional Kaluza-Klein lifts (in string theory and supergravity) stand as Theory proposal at the higher-dimensional layer with the same load-bearing open piece, since the SM never derives from the geometric primitives and enters only by hand. → deep dive
Einstein's unified field theory program (multiple attempts 1925-1955): it tried asymmetric metric and teleparallelism and distant parallelism and non-symmetric connection variants. All stand as Theory proposal claiming Physical theory at the geometric layer. None closed, since the matter sector never derived from the geometric primitives in any attempt and the empirical content reduced either to GR plus posited matter or to mathematical structures with no clear empirical regime. We read the program as the load-bearing demonstration of how broad the unification problem runs and how hard matter content resists derivation from geometric primitives alone.
Eddington's Fundamental Theory (Eddington 1936 Relativity Theory of Protons and Electrons, and 1946 Fundamental Theory, posthumous): it stands as Theory proposal claiming Physical theory, since it derived the fine-structure constant and proton-electron mass ratio and other dimensionless constants from group-theoretic structures (Clifford-algebra E-frames, finite combinations of group elements) combined with epistemological postulates about what observers can observe. The fine-structure-constant derivation moved from
Heisenberg's nonlinear spinor theory (Heisenberg 1957): it stands as Theory proposal, since a single nonlinear Dirac equation
Weyl's gauge theory (Weyl 1918): the original local-scale-invariance unification of gravity and EM stands as Mathematical exploration. It failed as physics on Einstein's pocket-watch objection, since a free-falling clock rate would depend on its path through the gauge field and that contradicts observation. The gauge concept survived in modified form (gauge invariance as phase rotation in QM) and it became foundational to the Standard Model. We count it as a mathematical exploration that succeeded by reinterpretation rather than by closing as originally posed.
Grand Unified Theories
SU(5) Georgi-Glashow (1974): it stands as Theory proposal claiming Physical theory, since it minimally embeds the SM gauge group in SU(5) and it predicts proton decay with lifetime ~10^30 years. Super-Kamiokande's proton-decay non-observation pushed the lifetime bound past 10^34 years and falsified it empirically at minimal level. It still teaches gauge unification and anomaly cancellation structurally, but it stays not viable in its minimal form.
SO(10): it stands as Theory proposal, since it embeds the SM gauge group in SO(10) and it accommodates a right-handed neutrino in the 16 representation while it predicts proton decay at longer lifetimes than minimal SU(5). It stays viable under current empirical constraints but it never derives the three-generation count or the Yukawa structure.
Pati-Salam (1974): it stands as Theory proposal, since it treats lepton number as the fourth color with gauge group SU(4)_c × SU(2)_L × SU(2)_R. It predicts heavy gauge bosons mediating quark-lepton transitions. Some variants survive current empirical constraints.
Flipped SU(5): it stands as Theory proposal, since it permutes particle assignments to evade some proton-decay constraints of minimal SU(5). It holds less institutional traction than SO(10) or Pati-Salam.
Trinification (De Rújula-Georgi-Glashow 1984, with Achiman-Stech 1978 antecedent): it stands as Theory proposal, since it carries gauge group SU(3)_C × SU(3)_L × SU(3)_R, the maximal subgroup of E6 under cyclic permutation, with the SM fermions arranged into the
Supersymmetry and supergravity
Supersymmetry as concept: it stands as Mathematical exploration, since a Lie superalgebra extends the Poincaré algebra with anticommuting generators and the structure stays mathematically well-defined. Whether nature realizes the symmetry stays a separate question that the mathematical structure never answers by itself.
MSSM (Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model): it stands as Theory proposal, since it adds superpartners at the TeV scale to the SM and it predicts specific signatures and lifetimes. LHC data through Run 2 pushed many MSSM signal regions to scales well above the "naturalness" expectation. The load-bearing open piece is whether the original naturalness motivation survives the empirical constraints. The program carries institutional pressure to shift to "Split SUSY" or similar variants.
Supergravity: it stands as Theory proposal, since gauged supersymmetry incorporates gravity and it derives gravity at low energy as a consistency requirement of the gauging. It serves as building block of string theory's low-energy effective field theory.
Split SUSY: it stands as Theory proposal, since it keeps gauginos at TeV scale with scalars higher (PeV-EeV). It evades some LHC constraints at the cost of giving up the naturalness motivation. It has lost institutional momentum.
Beyond Standard Model unification (non-GUT, non-SUSY)
Technicolor (Weinberg, Susskind 1979): it stands as Theory proposal, since it replaces the Higgs scalar with a fermion condensate of new "technifermions" in a confining gauge theory. The basic version stays mostly ruled out by the 125 GeV Higgs discovery (technicolor predicted no light fundamental scalar) and by electroweak precision tests. Walking technicolor and extended technicolor variants survive in academic conversation with reduced institutional traction.
Composite Higgs models: they stand as Theory proposal, since they treat the Higgs as a pseudo-Nambu-Goldstone boson of a strongly-coupled sector at higher energy. LHC data on Higgs couplings constrains them now, but they stay viable in specific corners of parameter space.
Randall-Sundrum (warped extra dimensions) (1999): it stands as Theory proposal, since a 5D warped geometry sets an exponential hierarchy between the Planck and TeV scales. It predicts Kaluza-Klein excitations at the TeV scale, and LHC constrains them.
ADD (large extra dimensions) (Arkani-Hamed, Dimopoulos, Dvali 1998): it stands as Theory proposal, since ~mm-scale extra dimensions dilute gravity. It predicts deviations from Newton's 1/r² at sub-mm scales, and short-distance gravity experiments constrain them. The original mm-scale formulation stays mostly excluded, and sub-mm versions remain.
Little Higgs models: they stand as Theory proposal, since they treat the Higgs as a Goldstone boson of a higher symmetry and they suppress radiative corrections by collective symmetry breaking. LHC constrains them.
Quantum gravity candidates
QG is where the bucket-collapse view does the most damage, since "Theoretical physics" gets treated as one bucket. QFT-on-curved-spacetime works as the calculational framework we have because QG stays unsolved (back-reaction is the open piece), and most QG candidates sit at Theory proposal while claiming Physical theory. We frame QG not as "unify QM and GR" (both stand as Effective models with Physical-theory components embedded) but as the project of identifying the Physical-theory layer that produces from a deeper substrate as derived consequences the currently-derived components of QM and GR (Dirac, spin-statistics, gauge invariance, anomaly cancellation, the GR vacuum field equations) and the currently-effective components (Born rule, commutators, Λ, ΛCDM parameters) with named regimes of validity and the currently-open structural items (back-reaction, SM gauge group choice, generation count, strong CP, hierarchy) either as derived consequences or honest deferrals. The three legs run sharper here. Leg A asks whether the candidate's primitives derive from its claimed substrate. Leg B1 asks whether the candidate does QM in curved spacetime (and cannot be evaded by self-labelling on intrinsically QM+GR phenomena like Big Bang dynamics, Hubble tension, Hawking radiation, inflation). Leg B2 asks whether the SM is recovered or the recovery defers.
String Theory: it stands as Theory proposal claiming Physical-theory status. Perturbative amplitudes on flat backgrounds stay admissible as Mathematical exploration, and they promote to Theory proposal where the work claims to describe reality. The ~10^500 vacuum landscape provides no mechanism to select the SM-yielding compactification. SM recovery stays open. As Physical theory in the QG discourse, fails B2 by leaving the SM recovery unconstrained. We read it as the cleanest case of institutional bucket-misrepresentation, since it stays admissible at Theory proposal and inadmissible at Physical theory. → deep dive
M-theory (Witten 1995+): it stands as Theory proposal, since it unifies the five string theory variants in 11 dimensions under one umbrella. It shares String theory's structural issues with empirical anchoring. It stays admissible at Theory proposal, not at Physical theory in QG discourse.
Loop Quantum Gravity: it stands as Theory proposal failing all three legs as Physical-theory QG. It quantizes geometry without deriving why geometry is the quantization target (fails A). Its semiclassical limit recovering smooth Lorentzian spacetime with matter QFT stays unresolved after four decades (fails B1). It never addresses matter content structurally (fails B2). It stays admissible as Theory proposal with interesting mathematical results. → deep dive
AdS/CFT: it stands as Mathematics-passing, physics-failing. As mathematics it conjectures a well-posed duality between two defined structures and it stays admissible as Mathematical exploration. As Physical-theory QG it runs a three-leg fail, since substrate (AdS₅ × S⁵, large-N 𝒩=4 SYM) isn't reality (fails A) and regime isn't our universe (fails B1) and boundary theory isn't the SM (fails B2). What stays structurally inadmissible is the deployment that cites AdS results as if they had established facts about QG in our universe.
Causal Dynamical Triangulation: we mark it as Passes A on its lattice prescription and it partially recovers semiclassical geometry in simulations while SM coupling stays unaddressed. It sits cleanly in Theory proposal with named open items.
Asymptotic Safety: it conjecturally passes A and B1 within truncation schemes for the gravitational RG fixed point. SM recovery from the fixed point stays open and never formed the programme's primary target. Honest deferral on B2. It stands as Theory proposal at the claimed and supported bucket.
Causal Sets (Sorkin 1987+): it stands as Theory proposal, since it treats spacetime as a discrete partially-ordered set with Lorentz invariance preserved on average. It derives a causal-discrete substrate while matter coupling and SM recovery stay open. It sits cleanly as Theory proposal with named open items.
Group Field Theory (Boulatov 1992 foundation, with Freidel-Oriti-Ryan 2005 matter coupling): it stands as Theory proposal, since a quantum field theory defined on copies of a Lie group (typically SU(2) for 3D) carries Feynman amplitudes that reproduce the spin-foam path integrals associated with Loop Quantum Gravity. It provides the second-quantised, sum-over-histories formulation of LQG dynamics, with the n-th Feynman graph corresponding to a triangulation of an n-dimensional spacetime. Matter coupling stays a major open programme. The 3D case with scalar matter stays partially understood (Freidel-Oriti-Ryan), while 4D extensions and SM coupling remain open. It inherits LQG's structural issues with semiclassical limit and matter sector.
Doubly Special Relativity (Amelino-Camelia 2000, Magueijo-Smolin 2002): it stands as Theory proposal, since it modifies special relativity at the Planck scale so the Planck length stays observer-invariant. It predicts Planck-suppressed deviations from Lorentz invariance, and high-energy astrophysical observations constrain them (GRBs, neutrino arrival times).
Horava-Lifshitz gravity (Horava 2009): it stands as Theory proposal, since it modifies GR by giving up Lorentz invariance at short distances to gain power-counting renormalizability. It suffers from extra scalar degrees of freedom that may couple strongly at low energy, and its structural status stays contested.
Massive gravity (dRGT) (de Rham, Gabadadze, Tolley 2010+): it stands as Theory proposal, since it gives the graviton a small mass without the Boulware-Deser ghost. Gravitational-wave observations from LIGO/Virgo constrain it (graviton mass < 10^-23 eV), and it remains a Theory proposal in the constrained corner.
Wave Relativity (Tan 2026): it Claims Physical theory with full decomposition. A closes, since it derives from three empirical anchors (Aharonov-Bohm, Newton, Davisson-Germer + Stern-Gerlach + Pauli) through self-consistency to one master equation. B1 closes via dissolution, since the sub-Planck QM-in-curved-spacetime question dissolves because matter wave and metric derive as aspect-projections of a single field Ψ, with both projections failing together at ℓ_P. B2 closes at tree level, since SM gauge group and fermion spectrum and generations and electroweak masses recover, with precision residue named. It names open items at the layer where they stay open. We use it as the contrast case for the framework. (Disclosure: the framework's author. WR is evaluated on the same standard as every other entry.) → deep dive
Verlinde's Emergent Gravity (Verlinde 2010+): it Fails A, since entropy gradients stand posited as gravity's source without derivation of why entropy specifically plays that role. It never addresses matter content. It stands as Theory proposal claiming Physical-theory status without the derivation to support it.
Shape Dynamics: it stands as Theory proposal, since it replaces ADM relativity's foliation choice with conformal invariance. It reformulates GR mathematically but it never addresses QG closure structurally.
Quantum Graphity (Konopka-Markopoulou-Smolin 2008): it stands as Theory proposal, since it treats spacetime as a dynamical graph with geometry emergent from graph dynamics. It stays underdeveloped relative to LQG or causal sets.
Modified gravity
MOND (Milgrom 1983): it stands as Effective model. It names the acceleration scale a_0 as empirical input. We mark it as Passes within the galaxy-scale regime it covers. It has not delivered a clean relativistic generalisation or SM coupling, and we name those as open items rather than burying them. → deep dive
TeVeS (Tensor-Vector-Scalar) (Bekenstein 2004): it stands as Theory proposal, since it generalizes MOND relativistically with tensor and vector and scalar gravitational fields. Gravitational-wave observations after the 2017 binary neutron-star event constrain it (the speed-of-gravity-vs-light constraint sits in tension with TeVeS's structure), and the load-bearing question is which TeVeS variants survive this constraint.
f(R) gravity: it stands as Theory proposal / Effective model, since it replaces the Einstein-Hilbert R term in the action with a function f(R). Specific f(R) choices fit cosmological data without dark energy, and the choice itself stays empirically motivated rather than derived. It counts as Effective model when f(R) is fitted and as Theory proposal when claimed as derived from a deeper principle.
DGP (Dvali, Gabadadze, Porrati 2000): it stands as Theory proposal, since it builds 4D gravity from a 5D braneworld with crossover scale. It predicted cosmological acceleration without Λ. Precision cosmology data rules out the self-accelerating branch, and the normal branch remains as a degree of freedom in modified-gravity searches.
Bimetric gravity: it stands as Theory proposal, since it runs GR with two interacting metrics and it relates to massive gravity formulations.
Mimetic gravity (Chamseddine-Mukhanov 2013): it stands as Theory proposal, since a constrained scalar-field reformulation of GR introduces a dust-like dark-matter analog without a new particle.
Cosmological and phenomenological proposals
ΛCDM: it stands as Effective model with embedded Physical-theory components. Its GR backbone inherits GR status. Cold dark matter and cosmological constant stay effective parameters. Inflation stays effective with multiple model families. BBN and CMB acoustic peaks stand as Physical theory within regime, depending on parameter inputs. Hubble and σ_8 tensions stay current open empirical residues, not yet structural failures. → deep dive
Cosmic inflation (generic) (Guth 1981, Linde 1982, Albrecht-Steinhardt 1982): it stands as Effective model with model-dependent variations, since it solves horizon and flatness and monopole problems within ΛCDM. The specific inflaton potential fits to CMB observables, and multiple models (chaotic, new, hybrid, R²) fit current data. It sits as Effective model with named effective parameters.
Eternal inflation (Linde 1986, Vilenkin 1983): it stands as Theory proposal, since inflation continues forever in some regions of spacetime and produces a multiverse. It inherits structural issues from the multiverse claim, since no derivation principle picks out our pocket-universe parameters.
Multiverse / String landscape: it stands as Theory proposal claiming Physical theory, since ~10^500 vacua carry different values of physical parameters and our values get anthropically selected. It structurally fails Leg A at the level required for Physical theory, since no derivation principle picks out our vacuum from the landscape, only anthropic post-selection. It supports at best as Theory proposal where the load-bearing question is whether the framework counts as "predicting" the SM via anthropic selection rather than derivation.
Steady State (Bondi-Gold-Hoyle 1948): it stood historically as Effective model, since it posited continuous matter creation to keep the cosmological-principle universe in steady state. The 1965 CMB discovery with QSO distribution and primordial helium abundance ruled it out empirically.
Plasma cosmology (Alfvén, 1960s-90s): it stood historically as Theory proposal, since it made cosmology dominated by electromagnetic effects in plasma, not gravitational expansion. The CMB blackbody spectrum with the failure to reproduce BBN ruled it out empirically.
Quasi-Steady State (Hoyle-Burbidge-Narlikar 1990s): it stands as Effective model variant of steady state with cyclical creation events. It carries the same empirical issues, and CMB acoustic-peak structure rules it out.
Tired light: it stood historically as Effective model, since it treated redshift as photon energy loss through space with no cosmological expansion. Supernova time-dilation observations with the surface-brightness Tolman test and CMB spectrum ruled it out empirically.
Variable speed of light (Moffat 1992-93 phase-transition formulation, with Albrecht-Magueijo 1998 smooth-variation formulation following): it stands as Theory proposal, since c varies in the early universe (much higher than today, then dropping at a symmetry-breaking phase transition or continuously) to solve the horizon and flatness and monopole and cosmological-constant problems without inflation. Current empirical constraints favour constant c at the
Cyclic / Ekpyrotic (Steinhardt-Turok 2001+): it stands as Theory proposal, since a cyclical universe replaces the singularity with brane collisions. It provides an alternative to inflation, and CMB tensor-to-scalar ratio bounds constrain it.
Conformal Cyclic Cosmology (Penrose 2010+): it stands as Theory proposal / Effective model, since it identifies future infinity of one aeon with the Big Bang of the next via conformal rescaling. Penrose's group claims empirical residues (Hawking points in CMB) but independent analysis contests them.
Paradox Engine Cosmology: it runs a Three-leg fail as Physical-theory QG. Its primitives (u, χ, ρ_c, C(t), kernel exponent 25/12) stay operationally defined rather than derived. It carries no quantum machinery or curved-spacetime evolution structure. It treats the SM as primitive labeled "resolved" without derivation. Its claimed bucket is Physical theory (unification of DM/DE/inflation/BH-info). Its actually occupied bucket is Theory proposal without derivation closure, with effective-phenomenology content sitting at the Effective model bucket.
Modern contested ToEs
Geometric Unity (Weinstein 2013+): it stands as Theory proposal claiming Physical theory, since it unifies via the "observerse," a 14-dimensional manifold with a metric tensor that produces both gauge fields and matter content. The full mathematical exposition stays at best partial in public, and the SM recovery (gauge group, three generations, Yukawa structure) has not been demonstrated. It stays admissible at Theory proposal where the load-bearing open piece is Leg B2 (recovery of established physics). The crank-discourse around the work runs heavy, and this verdict cuts independently of that. → deep dive
Wolfram Physics Project (Wolfram 2020+): it stands as Theory proposal, since it treats spacetime as a dynamical hypergraph with rewriting rules. It claims Lorentz invariance and time-reversal symmetry and SM recovery as emergent but never closes them. It stays admissible at Theory proposal, and open at Leg B1 (whether QM+GR machinery is recovered in the regime where the SM operates) and Leg B2 (SM recovery).
Lisi E8 (Lisi 2007): it stands as Theory proposal, since it treats SM + gravity as a single Lie group E8. It runs as a mathematically clean attempt. It broke on the three-generation count (the proposed embedding does not produce three generations without additional structure). It sits as Theory proposal with a specific named technical failure.
Penrose Twistor Theory (Penrose 1967+): it stands as Mathematical exploration with genuine mathematical merit (twistor space, twistor strings, BCFW recursion in amplitude calculations). Workers use it as a computational tool in modern scattering-amplitude work. It has not closed as Physical-theory unification. The connection to matter content never derived.
Penrose's Orchestrated Objective Reduction (Orch-OR) (Penrose, Hameroff 1989+): it stands as Theory proposal at the intersection of QM and gravity and neuroscience, since wave function collapse occurs via objective gravitational reduction in microtubules. Multiple components fail empirical scrutiny (the microtubule timescales for decoherence run much faster than Orch-OR requires). It stays admissible at Theory proposal with severe Leg B1 issues.
't Hooft Cellular Automaton interpretation (2014+): it stands as Theory proposal, since QM emerges from a deterministic cellular automaton at the substrate level. It sits alongside other QM interpretations. It stays open whether the deterministic substrate can reproduce the full QM with measurement, and how Bell's theorem is evaded (requires giving up some standard assumption such as statistical independence).
Smolin Cosmological Natural Selection (Smolin 1992+): it stands as Theory proposal, since each black hole spawns a new universe with slightly perturbed parameters and selects for universes that produce many black holes. It stays falsifiable on the neutron-star mass cap. Parameters tuned to maximise black-hole production force a soft hadronic equation of state, capping the maximum non-rotating neutron-star mass at ~1.6
Tegmark Mathematical Universe Hypothesis (Tegmark 2008+): Framework does not apply, since MUH abandons the Physical-theory derivation question by claiming all mathematical structures exist as physical realities. The structure that derives the SM is just one structure in the Level IV multiverse, with no derivation principle picking which structure corresponds to our universe.
Constructor Theory (Deutsch, Marletto 2013+): it stands as Theory proposal / Mathematical exploration, since it rephrases physics in terms of possible vs impossible tasks under counterfactual reasoning. It stays mathematically interesting. Whether it produces novel predictions that are not already in QM/GR stays currently contested.
Adinkras (Faux-Gates 2004-2005, with the DFGHILM collaboration extending the programme): they stand as Mathematical exploration, since they give a graph-theoretic representation of off-shell N-extended supersymmetric algebras in one dimension (supersymmetric quantum mechanics), with vertices labelling component fields and coloured edges labelling supersymmetry generators. They connect to Clifford algebras and doubly-even error-correcting codes and dessins d'enfants and Riemann surfaces, and they provide mathematical machinery for organising 1D SUSY representations. Gates and collaborators have speculatively linked the appearance of error-correcting code structure inside adinkras to a "code in the matter equations" substrate-physics interpretation. This speculative extension stays separable from the underlying representation theory and stays admissible at Mathematical exploration only with the substrate claim flagged as conjectural.
Quantum mechanics interpretations
Copenhagen Interpretation: it works as engineering framework, not a fundamental theory, since the projection postulate runs as operational rule. Admissibility criteria do not apply in the standard sense since it claims no derivational status. Operational adequacy is the relevant criterion.
Many-Worlds Interpretation: we mark it as Passes A on minimal primitives (state vector + unitary evolution) and it operates at the level B1 lives at, but derivation of Born-rule weights from branch measure remains contested. It stands as Theory proposal at the claimed and supported bucket with the Born-rule open item named.
Bohmian Mechanics: we mark it as Passes within non-relativistic QM via configurations plus guiding equation, while relativistic generalisation (Bohmian QFT) remains incomplete. Honest deferral on the relativistic side. It stands as Theory proposal at the claimed and supported bucket.
QBism: it sits in a different category, since it explicitly abandons derivational claims by treating quantum states as epistemic. Admissibility criteria do not apply in the standard form. QBism succeeds at what it claims, but what it claims differs from what the framework evaluates.
Consistent Histories (Griffiths 1984, Omnes 1988, Gell-Mann-Hartle 1990s): it stands as Theory proposal / engineering framework, since it treats QM as a calculus of consistent decoherent histories. Workers sometimes position it as a fundamental interpretation and sometimes as a tool for QM-on-closed-systems. It sits at Theory proposal when the fundamental claim is made.
Relational QM (Rovelli 1996+): it stands as Theory proposal, since quantum states are relations between systems, not properties of one system. The interpretation stays self-consistent. Whether it adds substantive content to operational QM or just relabels it stays currently contested.
Transactional Interpretation (Cramer 1986+): it stands as Theory proposal, since it treats quantum events as completed transactions between offer waves and confirmation waves, with relativistic-friendly time-symmetric structure. It holds less institutional uptake than MWI or Bohmian.
GRW Spontaneous Collapse (Ghirardi-Rimini-Weber 1986): it stands as Theory proposal with falsifiable predictions, since wave functions undergo random localisation events at a rate proportional to mass. The rate and localisation length stay empirical inputs, and matter-wave interferometry experiments constrain the model. It stays admissible at Theory proposal with named empirical parameters.
Continuous Spontaneous Localization (CSL): it stands as Theory proposal, since it runs as continuous-in-time version of GRW. It carries the same empirical-input situation, and ongoing experiments at increasing mass scales constrain it.
Diosi-Penrose gravitational collapse: it stands as Theory proposal, since gravity induces wave function collapse at a rate set by the gravitational self-energy of mass distributions. It predicts specific decoherence timescales, and workers test them at the boundary of current experimental sensitivity.
Stochastic Mechanics (Nelson 1966+): it stands as Theory proposal, since it derives non-relativistic QM from classical stochastic processes via the Madelung decomposition. It reproduces the Schrödinger equation mathematically but it runs into issues with relativistic generalisation and with multi-particle entanglement.
Modal interpretations: they stand as Theory proposal, since quantum systems have definite properties at all times, but which properties count as definite depends on the quantum state. Multiple variants exist (Kochen-Dieks, Bub-Clifton, perspectival) with no single dominant version.
Many-Minds Interpretation: it stands as Theory proposal, since it runs as a variant of MWI where branching sits in the observer's mental states rather than in the world. It holds less institutional uptake than MWI proper.
Passes, failures, and ruled-out cases name different kinds of verdict
Theory-level verdicts compress the component-level decomposition that Admissibility runs on. The framework page carries the worked decompositions (Dirac, GR, QM, SM, QFT-on-CS, ΛCDM, String, LQG) with operating notes for how to read passes and failures and the "ruled out" cases. "Passes" checks candidate status and never endorses. "Fails" gives the not-yet-a-candidate verdict and never refutes. "Ruled out" runs empirical and never structural.